Home - Sailing World Blogs - Two Innovative Takes on Improving the Sport

Two Innovative Takes on Improving the Sport

Posted 9 months, 3 days ago

Two Innovative Takes on Improving the Sport
Like many sailors, I have a love-hate relationship with the rules. I realize how important they are, and I often appreciate how they enable 40 or 50 or more boats to race on the same body of water and not descend into total chaos. But they can also be extremely frustrating and there's no question their complexity is a barrier for those hoping to break into the sport. Last week, there were two interesting "innovations" designed to make the sport less confrontational, for lack of a better word. Firstly, ISAF unveiled an experimental Introductory Rules for Sailing. They fit on one side of one page of paper and are easy to understand and remember. These rules certainly won't work in a big fleet of one-designs. But they're not designed to. They made for casual racing, for people who want to dip their toe in the water (I know, a weak pun). I think it's a great idea. The key to the success of these intro rules will be using them in the right situations. Any kind of aggressive racing will render them fairly useless. But as a tool to introduce people to sailboat racing, they could go a long way. You can find the rules at the link below. Check them out, use them if you think it's appropriate. Then let us, and ISAF, know how it turns out. Link for Introductory Racing Rules, http://www.sailing.org/22317.php Secondly, after some pretty crazy windward mark roundings during the first three regattas in the Jaguar Etchells series on Biscayne Bay, the race committee decided to try something new, windward gates. Jim Porter, who sailed with Jud Smith and Henry Frazer to second in the Midwinters last weekend, had this to say about the windward gates. Whether the Weather Gate By Jim Porter Due to the growth of the Etchells Jaguar series—this year an average of 82 boats entered the four regattas that make up the series—the race organizers decided to try something new to alleviate some of the congestion at the windward mark. During the first three events, the windward mark featured a lot of collisions and protests as boat tried to get around the windward mark and down the offset leg. So, the race committee for the Jaguar Midwinters last weekend (Feb. 29 to March 2) changed the sailing instructions to allow for windward gate. (To see what they did, check out the SIs at www.etchellsfleet20.org) The concept is similar to the leeward gates most racers have grown accustom too over the past few years. Pass between them, round one of the two marks, and head downwind. America’s Cup rules advisor Dave Perry, who was racing in the event, gave a short rules seminar during the initial skippers meeting. A large group of sailors were very concerned about port-starboard situations. Dave told everyone that the rules did not change for the burdened boat. The fleet was going to have to decide on two possible marks to round. Most of the skippers at the skippers meeting were opposed to the idea but the race committee decided to still move forward with the windward gates. Picking a gate and dealing with the rules went hand in hand. Depending on which gate you picked, you could end up going downwind without rights on boats still approaching the gates. However, we found that you had to go the favored gate. You couldn’t decide on one gate over the other because one offered an easier spinnaker set. You could lose too many places. At a normal windward mark the fleet pushes toward the left hand side of the course. And most boats stay on the “train” to avoid all the disturbed air produced by boats approaching the windward mark on the starboard layline. With two gates the fleet does spread out more quickly, but very often the initial lanes were slim and you were dodging boat that were still coming up wind. One of the mistakes initially was not having offset marks. The downwind angles after the mark put us bow-to-bow with boats still approaching the gate. The scariest time was when we rounded the right-hand gate and set on port jibe. We immediately became the burdened boat against the starboard tack lay line. We were caught off guard early because we were not able to jibe back to the middle due to the approaching traffic. During the first race with a windward gate, the lack of offset marks led to a few close calls and some collisions. The real confusion was between two boats on opposite legs on the same tack. To further separate the fleet, the race committee set up offset marks. This further spread the fleet out and avoided some of the bow on bow situations. The biggest complaint from the sailors involved getting away from the marks in traffic very hard, the first 5-10 boat lengths of the run. No matter which gate you choose, you were sent right into the approaching layline traffic. With a standard windward mark you are generally sent away from the approaching layline traffic. In one situation a boat that went around the left-hand gate and did a standard starboard bear away set headed into the approaching port tack lay line. A boat on port was barely clearing the starboard tack boat. But the port tack boat clipped the starboard boat ripped down its rig. No one was hurt but it showed how the fleet was being forced into each other. Spinnaker sets were a trial-by-error process. Since we never knew what mark we were going to pick until the last minute it was hard to prepare for the set. Several boats did not clip the spin sheets into the pole and tried to free fly the kite. This can work on some boats, but an Etchells is too narrow to effectively free fly a kite during the set. During the weekend we tried a number of ideas. We tried free floating the spin pole and then setting. The pole moved around so much we were afraid the pole would go straight through the kite. Next we tried hosting the pole and pulling it vertical alongside the mast. But the time to hook up the pole and sky it took too long on the offset leg. Our sets were very late. One boat sent the bowman forward to throw the spinnaker up in front of the boat. The skipper decided to jibe during the set and almost lost the bowman. The best method we found was to set up for a standard starboard rounding. If the left-hand gate was favored, we used the standard starboard-pole bear away set. If the right hand gate was favored. We had two options. The first option was to put the pole up on starboard with the guy in the jaws on the offset leg. The pole was hanging to leeward. At the offset mark we would jibe, push the pole forward and hoist. The second option was to hoist the pole on the offset leg, again on the leeward side. We would start to feed the sheet around, having the sheet in the pole helped it around the forestay. At the offset mark we would hoist the kite. Once the kite filled the pole would be moved to the windward side. Full Story »

Comments are currently disabled